tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1604477176521753208.post4217397843301703050..comments2024-03-14T19:25:05.015+08:00Comments on SAKMONGKOL AK47: A very preliminary thought on the 700 MHz spectrum.Ariff Sabrihttp://www.blogger.com/profile/04134536173557859031noreply@blogger.comBlogger32125tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1604477176521753208.post-71111010594678398602010-11-29T07:17:14.250+08:002010-11-29T07:17:14.250+08:00TM is the right operator , as the the neutral inf...TM is the right operator , as the the neutral infra provider , they have all the best hill , the cost will be cheaper . Let s content provider like RTM , Media Prima and YTL to lease channel from TM . What MCMC should do is to remove content monopolies by ASTRO.<br />TM board ,Ceo and management should be replaced , no imagination and vision since Khazanah took over.ChengHohttps://www.blogger.com/profile/04921277183237874214noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1604477176521753208.post-53448198330832974362010-11-28T18:12:52.488+08:002010-11-28T18:12:52.488+08:00Sak,
Stop being a sour grape. There are also lots...Sak,<br /><br />Stop being a sour grape. There are also lots of UMNO linked companies without any experience in anything except to enrich themselves who are given projects left, right and center by the government. I'm sure you know who these companies are...... so stop being a hypocrite.Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1604477176521753208.post-41463082125690770702010-11-28T12:53:45.921+08:002010-11-28T12:53:45.921+08:00mohdk.
i said let the infra be done by the govt. ...mohdk.<br /><br />i said let the infra be done by the govt. others later rent the space from the infra the govt build. see the difference? the actual services of LTE are provided by a a few operators who will be differentiated by their quality service and marketing prowess. <br />my question is why should YTL be given the head start while the other 4 telcos are not? YTL doesn't have the Ariff Sabrihttps://www.blogger.com/profile/04134536173557859031noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1604477176521753208.post-68352345531385259112010-11-28T12:41:01.102+08:002010-11-28T12:41:01.102+08:00With all due respect Dato'.
There is no way a...With all due respect Dato'.<br /><br />There is no way a GLC can run the business more efficiently than the private sector. Giving it to TM would be against making our domestic economy more competitive and is the kind of thinking that has seen our economy stagnate in the last 10 years against other countries such as Indonesia and Vietnam.<br /><br />Its unfortunate, but don't see TM beingmohdknoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1604477176521753208.post-13210771291291738472010-11-28T12:39:28.245+08:002010-11-28T12:39:28.245+08:00With all due respect Dato'.
There is no way a...With all due respect Dato'.<br /><br />There is no way a GLC can run the business more efficiently than the private sector. Giving it to TM would be against making our domestic economy more competitive and is the kind of thinking that has seen our economy stagnate in the last 10 years against other countries such as Indonesia and Vietnam.<br /><br />Its unfortunate, but don't see TM beingmohdknoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1604477176521753208.post-47590926467145619532010-11-28T12:38:39.130+08:002010-11-28T12:38:39.130+08:00With all due respect Dato'.
There is no way a...With all due respect Dato'.<br /><br />There is no way a GLC can run the business more efficiently than the private sector. Giving it to TM would be against making our domestic economy more competitive and is the kind of thinking that has seen our economy stagnate in the last 10 years against other countries such as Indonesia and Vietnam.<br /><br />Its unfortunate, but don't see TM beingmohdknoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1604477176521753208.post-23943414352641099492010-11-28T12:36:49.161+08:002010-11-28T12:36:49.161+08:00With all due respect Dato'.
There is no way a...With all due respect Dato'.<br /><br />There is no way a GLC can run the business more efficiently than the private sector. Giving it to TM would be against making our domestic economy more competitive and is the kind of thinking that has seen our economy stagnate in the last 10 years while other countries such as Indonesia and Vietnam have forged ahead.<br /><br />Its unfortunate, but don&#mohdknoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1604477176521753208.post-60595607657874320822010-11-28T12:36:34.743+08:002010-11-28T12:36:34.743+08:00With all due respect Dato'.
There is no way a...With all due respect Dato'.<br /><br />There is no way a GLC can run the business more efficiently than the private sector. Giving it to TM would be against making our domestic economy more competitive and is the kind of thinking that has seen our economy stagnate in the last 10 years while other countries such as Indonesia and Vietnam have forged ahead.<br /><br />Its unfortunate, but don&#mohdknoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1604477176521753208.post-11925227535804041292010-11-28T09:52:22.387+08:002010-11-28T09:52:22.387+08:00Dato, you are saying give everything to TM, I agre...Dato, you are saying give everything to TM, I agree on condition TM must be revamped.TM is monopolised, like you say, 'abang adiks' sitting there doing nothing but dishing out thing s for their own benefits. Clean TM starting from it's TOP especially those 'sitting ducks' at the helm of TM but know nothing about the industry. They are only serving their masters thats UMNO.<br Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1604477176521753208.post-32947187577694721562010-11-28T03:04:37.925+08:002010-11-28T03:04:37.925+08:00To put up the infra (towers, etc) to link up the w...To put up the infra (towers, etc) to link up the whole semenanjung with a 700 MHz wireless internet service will cost abt RM 250 mil to RM 300 mil only. Speed not as fast as wimax. But can do some 1Mbps - so much faster than streamyx.<br /><br />If YTL or Govt says it'll cost many RM biilions to do the infra...it's bullshit.<br /><br />The 700 to 800 MHz for just a state or two in the USAnonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1604477176521753208.post-87149002029141904762010-11-28T01:57:13.845+08:002010-11-28T01:57:13.845+08:00YTL does not have the expertise nor does it have t...YTL does not have the expertise nor does it have the RM8 billion. It will borrow from banks with its letter of recommendation from Min of Finance and roll that money elsewhere and then delay, ask for an extension, borrow more money and then launch the service...much like its 4G-Yes service. <br /><br />Why can't we have fair open tenders so that companies from abroad with their expertise can Sammyhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/07875768296412463654noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1604477176521753208.post-66270490295783943502010-11-27T21:02:28.581+08:002010-11-27T21:02:28.581+08:00gomen ni tak habis habis bela cina bg kayagomen ni tak habis habis bela cina bg kayaAnonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1604477176521753208.post-71401614476632604352010-11-27T19:29:42.160+08:002010-11-27T19:29:42.160+08:00Dear All,
I disagree with Dato's criticism on...Dear All,<br /><br />I disagree with Dato's criticism on one account. I see that YTL's forray into the telco sector will result in competition to Maxis and I am a simple guy.<br /><br />An enemy of my enemy is my friend. As such YTL is my friend.<br /><br />But my eventual hope is that both entities are engaged in price wars, have to spend billions in infra, and get upturned by a third Wenger J Khairyhttp://penumpang.blogspot.comnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1604477176521753208.post-22095741361581094972010-11-27T19:22:20.955+08:002010-11-27T19:22:20.955+08:00YTL had a real run in RMK9 with the corrupt Effend...YTL had a real run in RMK9 with the corrupt Effendi Norwawi at EPU. Who is is donkey now?Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1604477176521753208.post-11887299697145513322010-11-27T19:13:54.861+08:002010-11-27T19:13:54.861+08:00Dua sen,
Your idea is good but is there any intent...Dua sen,<br />Your idea is good but is there any intention to put the best brains in GLC? You just can't have clever people when there is ulterior motive. Kacau daun maa..<br /><br />Anyway, I salute Dato Sak for speaking out.Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1604477176521753208.post-61291222580558457272010-11-27T19:04:54.022+08:002010-11-27T19:04:54.022+08:00i guess LTE is still in formative stage...and no c...i guess LTE is still in formative stage...and no clear cut leadership on tech.Infra and handsets/devices needs to be synchronised to get max benefits.<br /><br />Its not so simple...<br /><br />Best is to set service standards,roll outs and charges and call for open bids.I would love to think that an all you can eat option of RM 30 per month for broadband should be the starting point.<br /><br />Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1604477176521753208.post-8856620617962345312010-11-27T17:59:37.177+08:002010-11-27T17:59:37.177+08:00Sak,
Before you continue with your suggestion of ...Sak,<br /><br />Before you continue with your suggestion of awarding TM the project, TM should replace their management and staff with the right calibre people to improve their services. I propose that TM should employ Quiet Despair as he surely has the credentials since he had lived and worked in the US and he claims to be smarter than most people that we know.Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1604477176521753208.post-80663693889614020252010-11-27T17:15:06.544+08:002010-11-27T17:15:06.544+08:00MR Prime Minister,
The company that you awarded I...MR Prime Minister,<br /><br />The company that you awarded IPPs, licenses and Big Contracts are really subscribing to your idea of 1Malaysia in their organizations. Not too long ago telecommunication expertise were majority Malays. It is no longer the case now. <br /><br />The Malays now only held high positions in Human Resource dept, Government Liaison and awarding contracts and licenses Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1604477176521753208.post-26266765098283471352010-11-27T16:47:35.805+08:002010-11-27T16:47:35.805+08:00tolong lah...ytl dah ada ipp...dah buat banyak bui...tolong lah...ytl dah ada ipp...dah buat banyak buit dah kaya raya....beri lah kepada yang lain...orang lain pon nak hidop juga....pm najib tolong buat lah sesuatu yang betul2 ikhlas untok raayak jelata...tunjok lah kepimpinan mu...Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1604477176521753208.post-22395742213312302852010-11-27T16:46:05.267+08:002010-11-27T16:46:05.267+08:00I say this for Najib - This is the era of GTP.
-E...I say this for Najib - This is the era of GTP.<br /><br />-E.G.Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1604477176521753208.post-27554030360700068672010-11-27T15:34:27.550+08:002010-11-27T15:34:27.550+08:00dato.
"i am saying because it belongs to the...dato.<br /><br />"i am saying because it belongs to the givernment, let it lay down the infra. then call the operators to bid for portions of the airwaves."<br /><br />What about that BIG undang?<br /><br />TM employes tons of Malay (whom's performances r been questioned by u). <br /><br />Moreover, what about the unwritten govt rule on any new tech ventures, be that petroleum, Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1604477176521753208.post-81266884281241072782010-11-27T15:05:36.294+08:002010-11-27T15:05:36.294+08:00Dato,
Agreed what was said.
Please note awardin...Dato,<br /><br />Agreed what was said. <br /><br />Please note awarding the 700 Mhz to YTL is already a competition to TM which are embarking on government fund (err public money) to lay HSBB and to provide IPTV. RM 5 billion if anyone can recall.<br /><br />As usual someone in the government or related agencies have screw-up big time to see the different.Asam Pedasnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1604477176521753208.post-33558670915003616522010-11-27T15:00:22.090+08:002010-11-27T15:00:22.090+08:00Dear Sakmongkol
I am 100% with you on this. There...Dear Sakmongkol<br /><br />I am 100% with you on this. There is some explaining by government to do why they keep giving out monopolies and always no tenders. We also need some explanation from MCMC. <br /><br />But Sakmongkol, this government will never learn. Isn't it time to try something new?OneMalaysiannoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1604477176521753208.post-61736665397958936032010-11-27T14:58:15.733+08:002010-11-27T14:58:15.733+08:00Assalamualaikum wbt Dear Datuk,
1.Frequencies are...Assalamualaikum wbt Dear Datuk,<br /><br />1.Frequencies are like land - it is an asset.It can be valued.And once you have infrastructure utilising the frequencies, then you make money.<br /><br />2.Unlike land, frequencies ALL belong to the country,ie. the rakyat and the government is the caretaker of this asset.<br /><br />3.In most of the countries belonging to the ITU - International Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1604477176521753208.post-84001113716674565902010-11-27T14:51:36.763+08:002010-11-27T14:51:36.763+08:00Isn't it all about kickbacks?Isn't it all about kickbacks?IbnAbdHalimhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/01218246428447808157noreply@blogger.com